More of the Same

In the first year after Baghdad fell to American forces, the American Coalition Provisional Authority set up its offices in Saddam Hussein's Republican Palace. The Bush administration chose young, inexperienced Republicans to put together the shattered Iraqi nation. George Packer describes the group in his book The Assassin's Gate: America in Iraq:

Most of them seemed to be Republicans, and more than a few were party loyalists who had come to Iraq as political appointees on ninety-day tours. They were astonishingly young. Many had never worked abroad, few knew anything about the Middle East, and that first summer only three or four of the Americans spoke Arabic. Some were simply unqualified for their responsibilities. A twenty-five-year-old oversaw the creation of the Baghdad stock market, and another twenty-five-year-old, from the Office of Special Plans, helped write the interim constitution while filling out his law school application. (184)

While these young people were enthusiastic and devoted Republicans, they were unprepared for the seriously important work at hand. They were chosen because they were ideologically correct.

Again and again over the past eight years the Bush administration has put ideology over competence and experience, from the members of the Coalition Provisional Authority to the director of FEMA to the selection of District Attorneys.

In his choice of Sarah Palin as running mate, John McCain is illustrating this same kind of governing. The problem is not particularly with Sarah Palin herself, who may be a wonderful person. The problem is with what her choice tells us about John McCain. All the pundits on television who are heralding this choice as an indication that John McCain is a maverick have blank slates for minds.

Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.